Hawaiian Roll Italian Sliders

These Italian sliders are little bites of heaven—savory meats, melty cheese, zesty pepperoncinis, and a tangy dressing, all packed into soft, buttery Hawaiian rolls. Whether you’re making them for a party, a quick family dinner, or just because you need some serious sandwich magic in your life, these sliders hit every mark.

Ingredients

You’ll need Hawaiian rolls for that sweet, pillowy goodness that balances out the salty meats. For the spread, you can go with mayo, Miracle Whip, or mustard—whichever vibe you’re feeling. We’re layering on ham, salami, and pepperoni for a trifecta of Italian deli perfection, plus Swiss cheese for that creamy, melty factor. Pepperoncinis add a little zing, and shredded lettuce tossed in a red wine vinegar and olive oil mix gives you that classic Italian hoagie feel. For the finishing touch, we’re brushing the tops with melted butter mixed with Italian seasoning and garlic salt because buttery, herby bread is never a bad idea. You can even use this amazing garlic butter sauce for a topping!

How to Make Italian Sliders

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F. Grab a baking dish and place the bottom halves of the Hawaiian rolls inside. Spread your choice of mayo, Miracle Whip, or mustard across the rolls to lay the foundation for all that flavor.

Now, it’s layering time. Start with the ham, followed by the salami and pepperoni. Lay down the Swiss cheese, making sure every bite is going to have that perfect cheesy pull. Scatter the pepperoncinis over the top for a little punch.

In a separate bowl, mix the shredded lettuce with red wine vinegar and olive oil. Set that aside—you don’t want to bake it with the sliders; we’re adding it at the end for the fresh crunch.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Nellie | Easy Recipes & Fitness Adventures (@glamnellie)

Pop the top halves of the rolls on, pressing them down gently to keep everything snug. Melt your butter and stir in the Italian seasoning and garlic salt, then brush this delicious mixture all over the tops of the sliders. Get ready for that golden, flavorful crust!

Cover the dish with foil and bake for about 10-12 minutes, then remove the foil and let them bake for another 3-5 minutes until they’re golden and the cheese is perfectly melted.

Take them out of the oven, lift the tops, and pile on that dressed lettuce. Slice, serve, and watch them disappear in seconds.

The first time I had Italian sliders was at my friend’s house during one of those game-day parties where everyone brings a dish. I took one bite and immediately side-eyed her like, “Sis, where have these been all my life?” The mix of salty meats, melty cheese, and that zesty pepperoncini bite had me going back for seconds… and thirds. She laughed and told me they were the easiest thing ever to make, and once I tried making them at home, I realized she was absolutely right. Now, they’re a regular in my kitchen, whether I’m feeding my family or just craving something ridiculously delicious.

These Sliders Are SO Fun to Make at Home

First of all, they’re crazy easy. No fussy steps, just layering, brushing with butter, and baking. Second, they’re totally customizable—you can switch up the meats, add more heat with extra peppers, or swap in provolone or mozzarella if Swiss isn’t your thing. And let’s not forget, they’re the perfect crowd-pleaser. Whether it’s a party, a lazy dinner, or even meal prep for the week, these sliders always hit the spot.

People run into a few common issues when making Italian sliders at home, but don’t worry—I’ve got you covered with easy fixes!

1. Soggy Bottom Rolls

Nobody wants a mushy sandwich! The issue usually comes from adding too much moisture—either from the dressing, the pepperoncinis, or steam from baking. Fix: Toast the bottom halves of the rolls for a few minutes before assembling. Also, make sure you drain the pepperoncinis really well before layering them on.

2. Sliders Falling Apart

If your sliders turn into a mess when you try to pull them apart, it’s usually because they weren’t pressed together enough before baking. Fix: When you place the top buns on, press them down gently so everything sticks together. Also, using enough cheese helps—it acts like a glue to hold everything in place!

3. Cheese Not Melting Properly

Sometimes the cheese doesn’t melt all the way before the tops of the rolls start to brown. Fix: Cover the sliders with foil for most of the baking time to trap the heat and ensure the cheese gets perfectly gooey before removing the foil for that golden finish.

4. Too Salty

With ham, salami, and pepperoni, things can get a little salty fast. Fix: Balance it out with a mild cheese (like mozzarella instead of Swiss) and be mindful of the added salt in your butter topping. You can also add a little honey to the dressing to cut the saltiness.

5. Rolls Getting Too Crunchy or Hard

If your rolls end up more like croutons than soft, pillowy sliders, they may have baked too long or at too high a temperature. Fix: Stick to 350°F and don’t overbake—just enough to melt the cheese and crisp the tops. Also, brushing the tops with butter helps keep them soft!

Why This Recipe Works

This recipe works because it nails the perfect balance of flavors—sweet from the Hawaiian rolls, salty from the meats, creamy from the cheese, tangy from the pepperoncinis, and buttery herb goodness on top. The contrast of warm, melty sliders with cool, crunchy lettuce makes every bite feel extra special. Plus, they’re quick, easy, and absolutely addicting. Trust me, once you make these, they’ll be on repeat in your house!

Here are some more tasty slider recipes to try: